✨ No fees unless we win.

Articles

How Comparative Fault Works in Rhode Island and Massachusetts

Partly at fault for a crash? Rhode Island and Massachusetts still let you recover, but the rules differ. Here's how comparative fault works.

Two dark sedans stopped nose to nose after a minor collision at a leaf-covered crosswalk on a quiet New England street on an overcast autumn day.

Being partly at fault for an accident does not automatically end your injury claim. Rhode Island uses pure comparative fault, so you can recover even if you were mostly to blame, with your award reduced by your share of fault. Massachusetts lets you recover as long as your fault is not greater than the fault of the people you are suing.

What is comparative fault?

Comparative fault is the rule that divides blame for an accident by percentage and reduces an injured person's compensation by their own share.

Insurance adjusters, and sometimes juries, look at what each person did and assign a percentage. If your damages are $100,000 and you are found 20% at fault, your recovery drops to $80,000.

Can I recover if I was partly at fault in Rhode Island?

Yes. Rhode Island follows pure comparative negligence under R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-20-4, so your own fault reduces your recovery but never bars it completely.

  • 10% at fault: you can recover 90% of your damages

  • 50% at fault: you can recover 50%

  • 80% at fault: you can still recover 20%

How is Massachusetts different?

Massachusetts uses modified comparative negligence under M.G.L. c. 231, § 85. You can recover only if your negligence is not greater than the total negligence of the defendants.

  • 50% at fault or less: you can recover, reduced by your percentage

  • 51% at fault or more: you recover nothing from the other parties

That one-point line is why fault arguments in Massachusetts cases can matter so much.

How do insurance companies use comparative fault?

Insurers often use comparative fault to lower what they pay. Common arguments include:

  • You were speeding or distracted

  • You weren't wearing a seatbelt

  • You were outside a crosswalk as a pedestrian

  • You didn't watch where you were walking in a store

Each percentage point shifted onto you reduces the value of your claim. Recorded statements, social media posts and gaps in medical care can all be used to support these arguments.

How can I protect myself from an unfair fault claim?

Evidence collected early is usually the best protection against being blamed for more than your share.

  • Photograph the scene, vehicles, road conditions and any hazards

  • Get names and phone numbers of witnesses

  • Request the police report and correct any errors you find

  • Ask about nearby video cameras before footage is erased

  • Be careful about giving the other driver's insurer a recorded statement

Does comparative fault change the deadline to file?

No. In both Rhode Island and Massachusetts, most personal injury claims must be filed within three years of the injury, whatever the fault split. Some claims, such as those against government entities, have shorter notice rules.

Key takeaways

  • Partial fault does not automatically end your claim in either state.

  • Rhode Island: pure comparative fault, so any share of fault only reduces your recovery.

  • Massachusetts: you recover only if you are 50% or less at fault.

  • Insurers often try to shift blame, so early evidence matters.

  • Most injury claims in both states have a three-year filing deadline.

Frequently asked questions

Who decides how much fault I have?

Insurance adjusters estimate it during settlement talks. If the case goes to trial, a judge or jury decides.

What if two other drivers were also at fault?

In Massachusetts, your fault is compared with the combined fault of all defendants. In Rhode Island, any amount of fault on your part only reduces your recovery.

Will admitting fault at the scene hurt my claim?

It can. Stick to the facts with police and avoid guessing about who caused the crash.

Does comparative fault apply to slip and fall cases?

Yes. It applies to most negligence claims, including premises and slip and fall injuries and car accidents.

Talk to a Rhode Island or Massachusetts injury lawyer

If an insurance company is blaming you for an accident that wasn't your fault, ACE Injury Attorneys can review your case for free. Call 401-4-ACELAW ((401) 422-3529) any time.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Lawyer portrait photo

Author

Anthony E. Conte, Esq.

Anthony E. Conte, Esq.

It’s Simple - You Pay $0 Unless We Win

Get a Free Case Review

Two vehicles damaged in a car crash

1

1

Tell Us Your Story

Contact us for a FREE, no-obligation case review and explore your options.

2

2

We Get to Work

Once you hire us, we handle the legal process while you focus on recovery.

3

3

Get Compensated

We fight for maximum compensation and only get paid if we win your case.

Why Choose ACE Injury Attorneys?

Personal injury cases require both compassion and aggressive preparation. At ACE Injury Attorneys, we understand the emotional weight these cases come with. We also understand how aggressively insurance companies and corporate defendants fight them.

When you hire ACE, you get:

  • Direct attorney communication

  • Honest case evaluations

  • Serious investigation

  • Litigation-focused preparation

  • Aggressive negotiation

  • A team focused on accountability and maximum recovery

We prepare cases thoroughly because insurance companies pay attention when they know a law firm is prepared to litigate.

Areas We Serve

ACE Injury Attorneys represents injured victims throughout Rhode Island and Massachusetts, including:

  • Providence

  • Warwick

  • Cranston

  • Pawtucket

  • Newport

  • Woonsocket

  • East Providence

  • Smithfield

  • Attleboro

  • Fall River

  • New Bedford

  • Taunton

  • Brockton

  • And surrounding communities

NEXT STEP: Call 401-4-ACELAW now or complete our free case evaluation form below for a free consultation with a personal injury lawyer nearby.

Why Choose ACE Injury Attorneys?

Personal injury cases require both compassion and aggressive preparation. At ACE Injury Attorneys, we understand the emotional weight these cases come with. We also understand how aggressively insurance companies and corporate defendants fight them.

When you hire ACE, you get:

  • Direct attorney communication

  • Honest case evaluations

  • Serious investigation

  • Litigation-focused preparation

  • Aggressive negotiation

  • A team focused on accountability and maximum recovery

We prepare cases thoroughly because insurance companies pay attention when they know a law firm is prepared to litigate.

Areas We Serve

ACE Injury Attorneys represents injured victims throughout Rhode Island and Massachusetts, including:

  • Providence

  • Warwick

  • Cranston

  • Pawtucket

  • Newport

  • Woonsocket

  • East Providence

  • Smithfield

  • Attleboro

  • Fall River

  • New Bedford

  • Taunton

  • Brockton

  • And surrounding communities

NEXT STEP: Call 401-4-ACELAW now or complete our free case evaluation form below for a free consultation with a personal injury lawyer nearby.

Why Choose ACE Injury Attorneys?

Personal injury cases require both compassion and aggressive preparation. At ACE Injury Attorneys, we understand the emotional weight these cases come with. We also understand how aggressively insurance companies and corporate defendants fight them.

When you hire ACE, you get:

  • Direct attorney communication

  • Honest case evaluations

  • Serious investigation

  • Litigation-focused preparation

  • Aggressive negotiation

  • A team focused on accountability and maximum recovery

We prepare cases thoroughly because insurance companies pay attention when they know a law firm is prepared to litigate.

Areas We Serve

ACE Injury Attorneys represents injured victims throughout Rhode Island and Massachusetts, including:

  • Providence

  • Warwick

  • Cranston

  • Pawtucket

  • Newport

  • Woonsocket

  • East Providence

  • Smithfield

  • Attleboro

  • Fall River

  • New Bedford

  • Taunton

  • Brockton

  • And surrounding communities

NEXT STEP: Call 401-4-ACELAW now or complete our free case evaluation form below for a free consultation with a personal injury lawyer nearby.

Free Case Review.
No Fees Unless We Win.

Need legal advice or have questions? Fill out the form or contact our office. You pay nothing upfront, nothing out of pocket, and no attorney’s fees unless we recover compensation for you.

We’re available to you 24/7

Direct access to your lawyer and legal team

Years of experience from an award-winning firm

If you can’t travel because of your injuries, we’ll come to you.

CALL 24/7 · FREE CASE REVIEW

401-4-ACELAW

RHODE ISLAND

536 Atwells Avenue, Second Floor, Providence, RI 02909

Massachusetts

82 Wendell Avenue, Suite 100, Pittsfield, MA 01201

We’ll Come to You

If you’re unable to travel because of your injuries, we’ll meet you at home, in the hospital, or another convenient location.

Text Us

Free Case Review.
No Fees Unless We Win.

Need legal advice or have questions? Fill out the form or contact our office. You pay nothing upfront, nothing out of pocket, and no attorney’s fees unless we recover compensation for you.

We’re available to you 24/7

Direct access to your lawyer and legal team

Years of experience from an award-winning firm

If you can’t travel because of your injuries, we’ll come to you.

CALL 24/7 · FREE CASE REVIEW

401-4-ACELAW

RHODE ISLAND

536 Atwells Avenue, Second Floor, Providence, RI 02909

Massachusetts

82 Wendell Avenue, Suite 100, Pittsfield, MA 01201

We’ll Come to You

If you’re unable to travel because of your injuries, we’ll meet you at home, in the hospital, or another convenient location.

Text Us

Free Case Review.
No Fees Unless We Win.

Need legal advice or have questions? Fill out the form or contact our office. You pay nothing upfront, nothing out of pocket, and no attorney’s fees unless we recover compensation for you.

We’re available to you 24/7

Direct access to your lawyer and legal team

Years of experience from an award-winning firm

If you can’t travel because of your injuries, we’ll come to you.

CALL 24/7 · FREE CASE REVIEW

401-4-ACELAW

RHODE ISLAND

536 Atwells Avenue, Second Floor, Providence, RI 02909

Massachusetts

82 Wendell Avenue, Suite 100, Pittsfield, MA 01201

We’ll Come to You

If you’re unable to travel because of your injuries, we’ll meet you at home, in the hospital, or another convenient location.

Text Us